Friday, January 22, 2010

Perfect Shoes

By my calculations I have exactly two moments of parenting brilliance. I have 546,987 moments of pretty mediocre stuff and approximately 364 times when I completely blew it. I am most often fixated on those times when I did something that is sure to make my children's future therapist shake their head but I love to tell the story of how I was super mom on those two occasions.

My favorite story can be pulled out in any number of situations. I can use it to convince people that I am not a complete marshmallow when it comes to my kids. I can be tough! I use it as an example of how my boy needs to feel a lesson and not just hear it. Or, I use it when I talk about the importance of following through with consequences.

When Bennett was in that 2 to 3 year-old range he was fond of removing his shoes right before we left the house each morning. If he were feeling especially cantankerous, he would throw his shoes down to the basement or hide them completely. I tried all the parenting suggestions: I offered rewards for compliance, I tried sticker charts. I tried crouching down to his level and sternly talking. One morning I even dropped my basket and screamed at him. Nothing worked. Finally I threw down the gauntlet: Bennett, if you take off your shoes, you will go to school without shoes.

The thing about threatening my children is that most of the time I have to carry through with the threat. When I throw something out there, I have to be sure I can execute. For example, when I threatened to put the television at the curb if they didn't stop begging to watch it during the week, Beth pulled me aside and threatened me.

As could be predicted, Bennett once again removed his shoes and stared at me with all the defiance a two and a half year-old boy can muster. I gathered my things, zipped up his coat and walked him and his sock-covered feet down the driveway in the slushy snow.

He fussed about his feet being wet and cold. I told him that I didn't understand how that felt since I had chosen to keep my shoes on. He whined all the way to pre-school about his feet. I calmly suggested that his feet might feel a little more comfortable had he worn his shoes.

Once at school, I unbuckled his car seat and had him walk across the ice and snow covered parking lot in his wet socks. When we entered his class he asked what he was supposed to do with the wet socks. I told him it was his choice. I pulled the teacher aside and discreetly handed her the shoes and a pair of dry socks. I told her to let him suffer for a good 20 minutes and then come to his rescue. I hugged my boy goodbye. Tears were spilling down his cheeks by this point. I never raised my voice. I resisted the urge for sarcasm. I wiped away his tears and explained that mama puts shoes on your feet to protect them.

Since then I have never, not once had a problem with Bennett taking off his shoes at an inappropriate time. For one shining moment, I was a rockstar in the parenting world.

Lesser parents, mere mortals were horrified at my actions. They explained that Bennett was merely trying to control a little piece of his world. They explained that by removing and hiding his shoes, he was in effect getting more attention and an extra few moments of my time. Someone even suggested that Bennett was removing his shoes because the ones he had were not "perfect" for him. She suggested that I buy a pair of light up shoes and another pair with his favorite action hero; a pair that closed with a velcro strap and a pair that had to be tied by older hands. According to her, Bennett should have 5-6 options and then choose his perfect pair each day. My first response was to laugh. Then I realized she wasn't trying to be funny. I hate when that happens. I couldn't even muster a reply. She had clearly ignored the "Say No to Drugs" campaign during her brain development years.

Maybe I gave Bennett his first lesson in making a decision based on pursuing perfection versus settling for something that works. I'm not sure if the shoes were his "perfect" pair. They fit. They were appropriate for the season. They kept his feet dry and warm. They did the task they were designed to do.

Early in my career I changed jobs every couple of years. I was determined to find the perfect one. The one where I was compensated appropriately, the one where I was appreciated for my contributions, the one where I wasn't assigned any unpleasant tasks. I changed jobs often. I've been in my current job for almost nine years. It is the longest I've been anywhere. It isn't perfect but it is pretty darn good.

My church isn't perfect. I used to think it was but then I got involved with boards and committees and governance. It's not perfect because we are a bunch of flawed humans who make flawed decisions and we do so with gusto. We seek to do better and sometimes we do. A lot of the time we fall short. We will never get it completely right.

This isn't big news, but I'm not perfect. I am not a perfect employee or a perfect parent or a perfect church member. There are a lot of books that describe ways to pursue excellence and perfection. I think the books often sell a fallacy. There should also be books about how to know when good enough is okay. There should be books and conferences that explain how sometimes the dogged pursuit of perfection leaves you with wet, cold feet.

The lesson that I was trying to teach Bennett was one that I re-learn most days. I could leave my imperfect job or my imperfect church. I just have to decide if the pain of going without is better than the not-so-perfect-but does-the-trick shoes.

5 comments:

Unknown said...

I absolutly LOVE reading your blogs, just wanted to let you know that :)

Unknown said...

This reminded me so much of Modern Family and also please have Brooke tell you someday of the Poo Monster and how my nephew will be in therapy later in life. And finally, Shel Silverstein...

"Almost perfect... but not quite."
Those were the words of Mary Hume
At her seventh birthday party,
Looking 'round the ribboned room.
"This tablecloth is pink not white--
Almost perfect... but not quite."

"Almost perfect... but not quite."
Those were the words of grown-up Mary
Talking about her handsome beau,
The one she wasn't gonna marry.
"Squeezes me a bit too tight--
Almost perfect... but not quite."

"Almost perfect... but not quite."
Those were the words of ol' Miss Hume
Teaching in the seventh grade,
Grading papers in the gloom
Late at night up in her room.
"They never cross their t's just right--
Almost perfect... but not quite."

Ninety-eight the day she died
Complainin' 'bout the spotless floor.
People shook their heads and sighed,
"Guess that she'll like heaven more."
Up went her soul on feathered wings,
Out the door, up out of sight.
Another voice from heaven came--
"Almost perfect... but not quite."

Di King said...

Smiling

Unknown said...

So your second moment of parenting brilliance is...?

Susan said...

Awesome. Absolutely perfect, and beautifully written as always. Plus, it's what I needed to read today, to be reminded that good enough is just that, both in parenting and at work. Thank you!